Buy now, pay later services have changed how customers shop online. But when you're choosing between Klarna, Afterpay, and Affirm for your store, one question matters more than most: who's on the hook when something goes wrong?
Understanding BNPL Merchant Liability
When a customer disputes a charge or fails to pay, someone has to cover that loss. With traditional credit cards, merchants often bear the burden through chargebacks. BNPL services handle this differently, and each provider has its own approach to merchant liability.
The stakes are real. A single fraudulent transaction can wipe out profits from multiple legitimate sales. That's why understanding how Klarna, Afterpay, and Affirm handle merchant risk is essential before you sign up.
How Klarna Protects Merchants
Klarna takes on most of the payment risk when customers use their service. Once Klarna approves a purchase, they pay you the full amount upfront, minus their fee. If the customer defaults later, that's Klarna's problem, not yours.
This protection covers most situations, including customer non-payment and fraud. However, you're still responsible for standard merchant obligations like delivering products and handling legitimate returns. Klarna will charge back transactions if customers successfully dispute them for non-delivery or quality issues.
The approval process happens instantly at checkout. Klarna uses their own risk assessment to decide whether to approve each customer. When they say yes, you get paid within days, regardless of how the customer's payment plan works out.
Afterpay's Approach to Risk
Afterpay operates similarly to payments like Klarna when it comes to merchant protection. They assume the credit risk once they approve a transaction. You receive payment upfront, and Afterpay collects from the customer over time.
The main difference lies in Afterpay's stricter approval criteria. They tend to decline more transactions than some competitors, which can mean lost sales but also reflects their careful risk management. This conservative approach helps keep their default rates low.
Afterpay does require merchants to handle refunds directly through their system. If you process a return outside their platform, you might face complications that could affect your liability protection.
Affirm's Merchant Liability Model
Affirm stands out among payments like Affirm competitors by offering different risk models. Their standard option works like Klarna Afterpay Affirm peers, with Affirm taking on the credit risk. But they also offer a merchant-funded option where you assume more risk in exchange for lower fees.
Under Affirm's standard model, they handle fraud and credit losses. You get paid within a few business days after shipment confirmation. The merchant-funded option can reduce your fees by several percentage points, but you'll need to absorb any customer defaults.
This flexibility appeals to businesses with strong fraud prevention and low return rates. If you know your customers well and have confidence in your risk management, the merchant-funded option could save significant money.
Comparing Chargeback Policies
While all three providers protect against customer non-payment, their chargeback policies differ in important ways. Understanding these differences helps you choose the right BNPL partner for your business.
Klarna maintains a relatively standard chargeback system. Customers can dispute transactions through Klarna's resolution center. You'll need to provide evidence like shipping confirmations and product descriptions to contest disputes. Klarna typically sides with merchants who follow their guidelines and provide clear documentation.
Afterpay streamlines dispute resolution but requires strict adherence to their policies. They handle most customer complaints directly, only involving merchants when necessary. This hands-off approach saves time but means you have less control over dispute outcomes.
Affirm provides detailed dispute notifications and gives merchants more time to respond than typical credit card processors. Their portal makes it easy to upload supporting documents and track dispute status. They also offer pre-dispute alerts that can help you resolve issues before they become formal chargebacks.
Fraud Protection Differences
Fraud protection varies significantly across Klarna Afterpay Affirm platforms. Each uses different technology and strategies to identify risky transactions.
Klarna employs machine learning algorithms that analyze hundreds of data points per transaction. Their system looks at device fingerprints, purchase patterns, and behavioral signals. They also maintain a shared database of known fraudsters across their merchant network. This comprehensive approach catches most fraud attempts before approval.
Afterpay focuses on identity verification and links purchases to verified phone numbers. Their system requires customers to have an established payment history before approving larger purchases. New Afterpay users face lower spending limits until they build trust through successful payments.
Affirm uses a combination of traditional credit checks and alternative data sources. They pull soft credit reports for larger purchases and analyze bank account connections. This thorough vetting process means fewer approvals but also fewer fraud losses.
Best Practices for Minimizing Risk
Regardless of which BNPL service you choose, certain practices will help protect your business from unnecessary liability.
Start by maintaining detailed shipping records. All three providers require proof of delivery to protect you from disputes. Use trackable shipping methods and require signatures for high-value items. Keep these records organized and easily accessible for at least six months.
Clear product descriptions prevent misunderstanding disputes. Include multiple photos, accurate measurements, and detailed specifications. The more information customers have before purchasing, the less likely they'll claim the product wasn't as described.
Fast shipping reduces the window for buyer's remorse and potential disputes. Process orders quickly and provide tracking information immediately. Consider offering expedited shipping options for BNPL purchases since customers often expect faster delivery when using these services.
Communicate your return policy clearly at multiple points during checkout. Make sure it aligns with your BNPL provider's requirements. Some providers require specific return windows or restocking fee limitations.
Monitor your approval rates and dispute ratios regularly. Sudden changes might indicate fraud attempts or problems with your product listings. Each provider offers merchant dashboards where you can track these metrics.
Making the Right Choice
Choosing between Klarna Afterpay Affirm depends on your specific business needs and risk tolerance. Consider your average order value, customer demographics, and current fraud rates.
Klarna works well for businesses wanting maximum approval rates with solid fraud protection. Their balanced approach suits most retail categories and customer segments. The quick payment timeline helps cash flow, and their merchant support is generally responsive.
Afterpay fits businesses targeting younger consumers who prefer simple, transparent payment plans. Their strict approval process means fewer risky customers but also potentially fewer sales. If you sell trendy or seasonal products, Afterpay's customer base aligns well with impulse purchases.
Affirm suits businesses selling higher-ticket items where customers need longer payment terms. Their flexible risk models let you optimize for either protection or lower fees. The detailed credit checking process works best for considered purchases rather than impulse buys.
Conclusion
When comparing Klarna Afterpay Affirm for your business, merchant liability should be a primary consideration. While all three protect you from customer payment defaults, their approaches to fraud prevention, dispute resolution, and chargeback handling vary considerably. Klarna offers balanced protection with good approval rates. Afterpay provides straightforward protection with stricter customer vetting. Affirm gives you options to customize your risk level based on your business model. Take time to understand each provider's specific policies and choose the one that aligns with your risk management strategy and customer base.
FAQ: Klarna, Afterpay, Affirm
Which BNPL service offers the best fraud protection for merchants?
Klarna provides comprehensive fraud protection using machine learning and shared fraud databases across their network. However, Affirm's credit check system catches different types of fraud, so the "best" protection depends on your typical fraud patterns and customer base.
Do merchants pay fees if a BNPL customer doesn't complete their payments?
No, with standard agreements from Klarna Afterpay Affirm, merchants receive full payment upfront regardless of customer payment completion. The BNPL provider assumes this credit risk, though merchants still handle standard responsibilities like shipping and quality issues.
Can merchants choose different risk levels with BNPL providers?
Affirm offers merchants the choice between standard protection and merchant-funded options with lower fees but higher risk. Klarna and Afterpay generally don't offer this flexibility, providing standard risk protection across all merchant accounts.
How long do merchants have to respond to BNPL disputes?
Response times vary by provider and dispute type. Affirm typically gives merchants 7-10 business days to respond with documentation. Klarna and Afterpay usually provide 5-7 business days, though this can vary based on the specific dispute reason.
What happens if a merchant accidentally processes a refund outside the BNPL system?
Processing refunds outside the BNPL platform can void your liability protection and create reconciliation problems. Always process returns through your provider's system to maintain protection and avoid potential double refunds or payment complications.
Ready to Block Chargebacks at the Source?
Chargeblast stops disputes before they damage your business. Our prevention alerts catch problems early, giving you time to resolve issues with customers before they escalate into costly chargebacks. Combined with the right BNPL provider, you'll have multiple layers protecting your revenue from both payment defaults and dispute losses. See how Chargeblast strengthens your payment strategy today.
